When your roof starts leaking or showing signs of damage, finding the right contractor quickly becomes a top priority. But with so many roofing companies in the Grand Rapids area, how do you know who you can truly trust? The best roof repair company isn’t just the one with the lowest price—it’s the one with proven experience, strong local reviews, and a reputation for doing the job right the first time. In this guide, we’ll break down what homeowners should look for and why one company consistently stands out in West Michigan.
| Feature / Company | #1 – Above Roofing | #2 – Melvin Belk | #3 – Premier Roofing Co. | #4 – Summit | #5 – Irish | #6 – Armor |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Years in Business | 30 years of trusted local service | 30+ years-locally owned since 1982 | Business Started Locally: 6/1/2006, website states 2008 |
10 years, Started 2015 | 9 Years, Started 2016 | 6 years, Business Started 2020 |
| Specialized Repair Team | Yes – Full-time employees dedicated for repairs, background checks | Residental & Commercial Roofing, Siding and Gutters | Emergency Response Crew | Emergency Crew-Commercial Only, Repairs available for Residental | Available 24/7 | Residental Roofing |
| Geographic service area | West Michican, including Grand Rapids, Grandville, Wyoming, Ada, Holland, Jenison, and the lake shore, Holland and Grand Haven. | Kent County, Ottawa County, Allegan County, and neighboring areas | West Michican, Lakeshore/Musegon, GrandHaven, Cadillac & Kalamazoo. | West Michigan, Northern Michigan, & Metro Detroit | Grand Rapids, Portage, Kalamazoo and surrounding areas | Byron Center, Wayland, and Caledonia, MI, as well as surrounding communities in the greater West Michigan region. |
| Ownership | Family owned, Local and faith based | Family Owned; Mr. Melvin Belk, President/Owner | Private Equity | LLC, John VanWylen, Co-Owner | Private Equity | Family Owned; Mr. David Strotheide, President/Owner |
| Emergency Leak Response | Next-day or sooner in most cases | Emergency Roofing, no time period provided | 24/7 Emergency Crew, usually within 24 hours. | 24/7 for Commercial only | 24/7 | |
| Types of Repairs Offered | Shingles, ventilation, flashing, skylights, insulation, new downspouts, gutters, chimneys, and more | Roof Leaks | Shingle Roof | Residental Shingle Roof, Ventilation Commercial repairs as well | Leaky Roofs, Valley Repair, Chimney, Flashing, & more | Missing or damaged shingles Roof leaks or water damage |
| Repair Process | 5-step Hassle-Free Process for repairs too (Listen, Inspect, Recommend, Install, Support) | 5-Step Process (Initial roof inspection, Transparent estimate, Repairs, Follow up, Job completion) | Process begins by gathering information about your roof and current condition, then repairs performed, then final walk through | Call for free Consultation | Talk to an expert — Call 24/7 | We take time to explain your options, work efficiently, and follow through on repairs |
| Training | In-house training. Your roof will not be our learning experience | Training from GAF, National Roofing Contractors Association | ||||
| Pricing Clarity | Fixed, honest pricing—no oversell, no surprises | Honest, Clear Estimate | Transparent pricing | Upfront pricing, no surprises | Detailed estimate of the work required. We aim to be transparent throughout | Free estimates and honest, competitive pricing with no pressure |
| Communication During Repair | Clear, respectful, and proactive | unknown | Available before, during and after job is complete | Communicate clearly from start to finish | Clear Communication, honest service | |
| Technician Certifications | Trained, ethical, and certified repair techs | in house crews | Skilled Professionals | Experienced installers | ||
| Workmanship Guarantee | Lifetime workmanship warranty, even on repairs | Unknown for Repairs | Lifetime Workmanship Warranty; unclear if this applies to repairs | Unknown for Repairs | Unknown for Repairs | Unknown for Repairs |
| Customer Experience | Care-first, educational approach – no pressure, no panic | Customer Satisfaction Guarantee | Friendly service, and a team committed to treating your home like their own. | Obsesssed with earning your trust and satisfaction | Customer-first approach, true partnership | Quality, transparency, and your total satisfaction. |
| Reputation for Repairs | Hundreds of 5-star reviews specifically for roof repair + service | 4.9+ Stars on Google | 4.9 + Stars on Google | 4.9+ Stars on Google | 4.7+ Stars on Google | 5.0+ Stars on Google |
| Community Connection | Deep roots in Grand Rapids; supports Humane Society of West MI | Community Centric Approach; care deeply about our community | Chamber of Commerce SW MI (Kalamazoo, Caledonia), Featured on EightWest TV Show, & South Haven Humane Society | Nothing Found | Family Network Of Wyoming, National Night Out | Byron Center Chamber of Commerce, Misc community sponsorships |
| Unique Differentiators | 🚨 Fast emergency response, repair-only team, lifetime warranty, true local roots | Comprehensive Roof Repair Process | 24/7 Response Team | 24/7 Service for businesses and organizations | National Network | Claims to have over 40 years of experience in roofing |
Choosing the best roof repair company in Grand Rapids ultimately comes down to trust, craftsmanship, and long-term value. A company that combines decades of experience, strong community reputation, and reliable warranties gives homeowners confidence that their investment is protected. With over 25 years of service, industry certifications, and hundreds of positive reviews, Above Roofing has built a name that local homeowners continue to rely on for dependable repairs and honest guidance.
If you’re dealing with a roof issue, the smartest next step is simple—work with a team that prioritizes quality, communication, and lasting results.
